• Home
  • About Us
  • Programs
  • Class Schedule
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Blog
Kung Fu For Life | Martial Arts in Calgary
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Programs
  • Class Schedule
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Programs
  • Class Schedule
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Blog
Phone: 403.243.LIFE (5433)

Competition Training vs. Self-defense Training

4/9/2018

6 Comments

 
competition training vs self-defense training

Kung Fu Competition Training vs. Self-defense Training

It is important to understand that you don’t have to compete in order to learn self-defense. The origin of our system, shaolin, was never meant for competition. It was designed to create good health, focus of mind and body, and of course learning to defend oneself.

Sometimes what you might think looks barbaric in the fighting ring, is actually civilized when compared to advance self-defense training. Ring fighting contains only a portion of true Kung Fu/ martial arts.
Let us start by saying, there is only one true competitor in your life and that is the person looking back at you in the mirror. We will explain in point-form the main differences of self-defense and competition training.

  1. Competition in a ring has limited space to work in
  2. A referee
  3. Rules
  4. Prearranged time
  5. You know your opponent and can study their weakness
  6. 2-3 minute rounds
  7. Pre-fight warmup
  8. Two aggressors
  9. No exit strategies
  10. A personal trainer right there with you in your corner

So let’s address each one for now - competition versus self-defense.

1. Limited space, this is also often the case in self-defense as a matter of fact, much less space is usually available compared to the ring. So close-quarters fighting techniques is an absolute must.  Sometimes there is much more space than you would ever find in a ring. Remember that the only thing that matters in self-defense is self-preservation, you must do whatever it takes, including running away.  There’s no rules, no competition, no crowd to impress, just defending yourself! True self-defense has a foundation in both common sense and ethics. Before you ever lift your hand to hurt another human being, it must be warranted.

2. A referee is there to ensure that no competitor gets out of hand, gets severely injured or killed. He is the calming agent between the two fighters, reminding them at all times to follow the rules.

In self –defense, of course, there is no such person mediating anything or protecting you from what your assailant is going to do to you, it is just you and your attacker.  There is only one outcome and it must be that you survive. You aren’t a winner or victor but rather the survivor for life not glory.

3. Rules. There are all kinds of rules in competition, and you can thank civilized man for that. Just remember there’s no rules in self-defense, except maybe the law and that’s only after the fact, unless you’re very lucky.  In Roman times, the spectators were the true barbarians and they promoted the violence. Unfortunately, you still see some of that today, not just in martial arts but in many sports, more blood, more cheering, lots of big mouths calling out for more violence… it’s easy when it’s not their own blood.

4. Prearranged time in competition, this allows many variables to be somewhat predictable within reason, good fighters know this and plan a couple surprises for their opponents. Self-defense situations always have an element of surprise which causes confusion, fear, hesitation, and sometimes locking of the body (also known as freezing). Which is natural but nonetheless can be very irritating and restricting.   Examples of this are, you can be carrying your groceries to your car, riding on the bus, sitting at a donut shop, or any number of tasks we do every day when an attacker comes at you. One of the best ways to avoid these predicaments is to remain aware of your surroundings at all times which allows you more options than just self-defense. This could include calling 9-1-1, avoiding the potential danger by exiting, or finding another way around it. Good teaching promotes the understanding of self-defense is far more than just hand to hand combat.

5. Know your opponent. For competition there are many ways to study the strengths and weaknesses of your opponent.  For example, watching recordings of past fights, physically seeing their fights, watching old interviews, and yet there are still many other ways.  In self-defense, obviously, there are no such observations possible. There is little to no idea of your attacker’s skill or intentions, other than obvious postures. How do you compensate for this? There are numerous ways, but no matter which you choose, you are forced to react (after exhausting all non-violent measures).  You have to use any techniques that will work and must exert 100% effort until the threat is gone. When the attacker has forced you to the point of no return... fight for your life!

6. Rounds. There are 2-3 minute rounds with rest in-between.  In Self-defense there is no rest, as I mentioned before no referee, no choice, and no rules.

Most self-defense if properly taught will only last a couple of seconds, maximum a minute, any self-defense that lasts longer is considered a very long time. The energy used during that minute is equivalent to over half an hour of an intense work out, depending on the intensity used. As well, you are dealing with other energy draining problems such as nervous tension, possible lock up, anxiety, maybe fear (which is totally okay). Remember hurting others is not normal or natural, even in our own self-defense.  Like we said before you must defend yourself!


7. You get time to prepare for the fight, sometimes months.  Pre-fight warm up in competition is also possible. As a matter of fact, it is absolutely necessary in order to prevent injury and have better reflexes and movement.  Self-defense must include cold response training methods. This can be very difficult to do because the lack of a warmup that may cause injuries to occur. We don’t do it all the time, but often enough to make it work.  However, our students always step into the martial arts hall with a certain state of readiness. Because of this our main teaching methods always include situational awareness training, which is an important tool for self-preservation.  Obviously you can’t know when a self-defense situation will occur so there is no chance for a warm up. The main tools of mental preparation for this case are conscious and subconscious recall.

8. In competition there are two people who want to fight, both want to win but only one will.  Both are already warmed up, they have been training for months and have done their homework beforehand.  In Self-defense there is at least one aggressor and one defender who does not want to be in the situation at all.  An attacker usually makes the first move and has the element of surprise. If you have no inclination of the attack and get surprised, being aware of your surroundings beforehand and having proper training can put the advantage back in your corner.

9. No exit strategy. In the ring, no one wants out. However in self-defense there are many exit strategies.  A good martial arts teacher will show you the way to leave a situation or at least come up with a non-violent solution.  Peace should always be the top priority.

10. Your trainer is right there with you in the corner of the ring.  This is an amazing advantage. If you could have your teacher right there telling you what to do when you get attacked it would seem 10x easier.  Unfortunately there is no chance of this ever happening. The best you can hope for is that you listened so carefully to your teacher that the master’s words flow to you like water; as if they were right there with you, telling you what to do, while you’re getting attacked.  Otherwise (and for the most part this is always true), you’re on your own and every move is your call. Whether it’s the right or wrong move it’s totally up to you.


Training for competition is good for health and self-defense, but you DO NOT NEED to compete in order to learn excellent self-defense, because there is only one true competitor in your life, and that’s the person looking back at you in the mirror.

6 Comments
Tyson Lehner
4/9/2018 07:42:19 pm

Couldn’t agree more with this. Very well put together good job!

Reply
David Hoyt link
4/16/2018 10:18:32 am

Great post! While I'm a self defense guy, I also enjoy the competition and the art in martial arts. In true JKD philosophy, I will take what's "street useful" and keep that in my repertoire, but it doesn't stop me from learning everything about a system. Thanks for sharing!

Reply
Philippe Lavoie link
5/11/2018 09:01:13 am

If compedition is not mandatory stress training, resistance training and confrontation training are. They are a absolute necessity (not a fun one) if you wish to bring your art in a self defense situation. In other word you need to have your ass kick often to be able to kick ass later.
Compedition and hard sparing are a way to achieve this. New age thinking may serve you well in your marketing strategy. But it will not serve you well, and your students, against the average aggressor. Many “masters” have the same opinion and get their ass kick by amateur MMA practitioners or the average John Do.
As a Chinese boxing teacher myself I know there is more than one aspects of the practice. But practicality in personal protection and combat situation is like the thumb of the practice. If you do not practice it seriously, you cannot grab it.
For the last word if you teach only for health and personal grow it’s okay. It’s maybe the best thing, since there is nothing honorable in hurthing people. Many students I have are only there for that. But they know it’s not sufficient to effectively defend themselves (or at least I have tell them). But as a Chinese boxing representative we should not make people believe they can defend themselves only practicing “deadly” techniques on a collaborative Kung Fu brother/sister and without consequent hard training. It is moraly and intellectualy incorrect.
Wish you all the best in your practice and reflexions on Chinese boxing!
PS: I’m French native so sorry for my bad english

Reply
Honesty Please
8/11/2018 08:13:12 pm

TLDR: It’s NOT effective self defense if it doesn’t work.

I agree with Philip Lavoie's post, it should be read carefully by anyone thinking they're actually training self defense.

Having trained the style at KFFL as well as many others, it comes down to this. Either:

1. You really believe what you're training is super deadly and going to help you in dangerous situations (I can emphatically tell you it WON'T. There is a severe lack of stress training, resistance training and confrontation training in this style). Passing along this mindset to students is extremely dangerous.

OR

2. As an instructor, you KNOW it's not realistic but continue to pitch this angle as it's key to marketing.

I'm hoping it's the former, as the latter is unethical to no bounds. Feel free to sell your brand as something for health and personal growth, but it's extremely disingenuous to claim it as an effective self defense tool.

Many of the points made here as being negative aspects to sports competition are actually just safeguards to ensure you can train at maximum intensity without incurring or inflicting severe injury. There are multiple layers to appreciate in combat sports, not just mindless blood-lust, as is implied here. If you know what to watch for, there is a lot of skill to appreciate in such athletes. Yes, combat competitions are only one aspect of martial arts, but it shouldn’t be discounted so readily, and certainly shouldn’t be framed so simplistically as “our way vs. the MMA way”.

I agree that everyone should train martial arts, but it should be done so in a truthful context: if your art isn’t equipped to teach and deal with real self defense applications and scenarios, then it should be honest and upfront about it.

Reply
David Hoyt link
8/12/2018 12:17:52 am

Great post. I just wanted to say that I agree 100%.
Both those of training are fine, as long as you're open about it.

Seth Dean link
12/23/2020 11:58:25 pm

Thanks for writing this.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Kung Fu For Life

    Learn something new from us each and every month!

    Categories

    All
    Competition
    History
    Kids
    Legalities
    Martial Arts
    Meditation
    Mind
    Mma
    Questions
    Retreats
    Self Defense
    Stories
    Teachers
    Weapons
    Women

    RSS Feed

About
• Our Story
• Why Choose Us?
• Martial Arts in Calgary
• Testimonials
Getting Started
• Classes & Lessons
• Programs
• Kung Fu For Kids
• Team Building
Contact Us
403.243.5433
345 39 Ave SE

Calgary, AB T2G 1X5
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Programs
  • Class Schedule
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Blog